Two traders are suing Polymarket, alleging the platform changed market rules to deny payouts related to a Bitcoin sale by Strategy.
Summary
- Two traders have filed a lawsuit against Polymarket in New York, alleging the platform mismanaged a market regarding Strategy's Bitcoin sales.
- The plaintiffs claim Polymarket's decision to resolve the market as "No" was based on a retroactive change of rules, despite Strategy selling 32 BTC.
- The lawsuit seeks $1 per share for the traders' "Yes" shares and additional damages from Polymarket's CEO Shayne Coplan.
In a significant legal challenge, two traders have initiated a lawsuit against Polymarket, a prediction market platform, alleging that the company altered market rules after the fact to deny payouts tied to a Bitcoin sale by Strategy.
William Wood and Thomas Bush filed their complaint with the New York Supreme Court on July 3, naming Polymarket's CEO Shayne Coplan and CMO Matthew Modabber as defendants.
1 month ago, Polymarket scammed me for $500K, with 1,868 traders losing a total of $6.5M.
Now we're taking Polymarket to court. https://x.com/willo2_Poly/status/2074214159261053207
— willo2 (@willo2_Poly) July 6, 2026
The lawsuit accuses Polymarket of multiple infractions, including breach of contract and deceptive practices, seeking compensation for the value of their shares and legal costs.
Disputed Bitcoin Sale by Strategy
The crux of the case revolves around a market that questioned whether Strategy would sell Bitcoin by May 31. Led by Michael Saylor, Strategy did sell 32 BTC, disclosed in a June 1 SEC filing, marking its first sale since 2022. However, Polymarket ruled the announcement was made too late, resulting in a "No" outcome after a vote by UMA holders, the oracle used by Polymarket.
Strategy is poised for further sales, announcing plans to divest up to $1.25 billion to bolster dividends, including a recent $216 million Bitcoin sale as part of its monetization strategy.
The plaintiffs argue that the SEC filing should have been sufficient evidence to validate the market's outcome, contending that the retroactive confirmation deadline undermined Polymarket's commitment to delivering objective results. They assert that a market ignoring verified events fails to pursue truth and manipulates payouts.
Polymarket's Controversial Reputation
In 2026, Polymarket has seen over 1,150 disputed markets, surpassing the previous year's total. Investigations have highlighted that a few large wallets disproportionately influence market outcomes, raising concerns about the integrity of UMA voters who may have vested interests in the markets they adjudicate.