A New York court dispute over 39,069 dormant Bitcoin addresses raises questions about ownership and legal definitions of property.
A legal dispute in New York's Supreme Court has emerged over the ownership of 39,069 dormant Bitcoin addresses, which reportedly hold around 3.799 million BTC (approximately $231 billion). The case was initiated by plaintiffs Noah Doe and two Wyoming companies, who argue that these assets are abandoned property and should be transferred to them.
The defendant, known as John Doe 33, has filed a motion to dismiss the claims, asserting that Bitcoin addresses cannot be treated as legal entities. He contends that merely reporting public blockchain data does not establish ownership, and that the pseudonym he uses is for privacy and security reasons.
Case Details
The plaintiffs base their argument on New York’s personal property law, claiming that dormant wallets qualify as unclaimed property. However, Doe 33 argues that the addresses cannot be legally recognized as found property, as they are not entities capable of being sued.
Notably, the addresses in question are publicly linked to Satoshi Nakamoto and the infamous 1Feex address tied to the Mt. Gox hack, whose current controller remains unidentified. John Doe 33 has also been linked to a wallet containing 5,000 BTC, valued at around $300 million, which has remained inactive since 2014.
Galaxy's head of research, Alex Thorn, highlighted that the emergence of Doe 33 as a defendant changes the dynamics of the case, as he raises significant jurisdictional and legal challenges to the plaintiffs’ claims.
Legal Implications of Inactivity
Industry expert Ian Cohen submitted an amicus curiae brief arguing against the plaintiffs' position, stating that a lack of activity does not equate to abandonment. He emphasized that New York's abandoned property law specifies that virtual currencies should be transferred to the state, not to private entities.
According to research from Bitbo, around 3.5 million BTC have not moved for over a decade, and another 6.6 million BTC have been dormant for more than five years. This raises the possibility that many of these coins are securely stored or lost, with access dependent on inheritance or key transfer.
This case marks a significant moment in the evolving legal landscape surrounding cryptocurrency ownership and property rights, particularly as it relates to dormant assets.