Back to News
CryptoRegulationBitcoin

Digital Chamber Urges Court to Dismiss Lawsuit Over Inactive Bitcoin Addresses

The Digital Chamber requests the dismissal of a lawsuit regarding inactive Bitcoin wallets, warning of risks to digital asset custody.

Mercation Admin
July 7, 2026 2 min read
Digital Chamber Urges Court to Dismiss Lawsuit Over Inactive Bitcoin Addresses

The Digital Chamber, a prominent blockchain advocacy group, has submitted an amicus brief to the New York State Supreme Court, urging the dismissal of a lawsuit related to dormant Bitcoin wallets. The organization cautions that labeling these inactive addresses as abandoned property could jeopardize the self-custody of digital assets.

Representing over 250 stakeholders, including cryptocurrency exchanges and financial institutions, the Digital Chamber argues that if the court sides with the plaintiffs, it could set a precedent that interprets inactivity as a sign of relinquished ownership.

"The plaintiffs are claiming ownership rights to hundreds of billions of dollars in digital assets simply because these assets have not been moved or spent," the brief asserts.

The lawsuit was initiated by Noah Doe alongside two Wyoming-based companies, ABC Company and XYZ Company, who claim the coins in question are abandoned and seek to assert ownership rights. In an effort to substantiate their claims, Doe developed an algorithm in 2024 that identified 42,001 inactive Bitcoin addresses, which he recorded and reported to the New York Police Department.

However, the Digital Chamber contests this claim, stating that Doe did not discover the wallets themselves but merely recorded public key addresses.

"What he 'found' were not the wallets themselves, but electronic records of the digital wallet addresses — that is, public keys," the brief states.

Following their identification, the plaintiffs attempted to contact the address owners, providing a 90-day notice to demonstrate activity. Of the original addresses, 2,932 were excluded after showing on-chain activity, leaving 39,069 deemed abandoned.

The Challenge of Ownership

Even if the plaintiffs succeed in their claims, they still face the hurdle of accessing the coins without possessing the private keys. The Digital Chamber highlights that true ownership and access remain with the original holders.

"The claim sought by the plaintiffs would provide a paper title of ownership that is not connected to possession or access to the property it allegedly conveys," the brief explains.

Previously, Bitcoin attorney Ian Cohen filed an amicus brief in May advocating for dismissal, arguing that laws regarding found property apply to tangible items, not digital assets identified through blockchain scans. John Doe 33, a pseudonymous defendant, also filed a motion to dismiss, asserting that blockchain addresses cannot be legal defendants.

Notably, John Doe 33 is associated with a wallet holding 5,000 BTC, which has remained untouched since April 2014, valued at approximately $300 million, according to Galaxy's research head, Alex Thorn.

Recent Activity in Inactive Addresses

In a surprising turn, 31 addresses from the plaintiffs' list began transferring BTC, with 17,527 BTC moved in June 2026, a significant increase from the previous activity of only 4,834 BTC in February. One notable transaction involved the address 1KV47, which transferred 30 BTC worth about $1.88 million, marking its first activity in nearly 15 years.

— Alex Thorn (@intangiblecoins) July 5, 2026

Court documents reveal that approximately 3.799 million BTC are tied to the 39,069 inactive addresses, including those linked to Satoshi Nakamoto and the infamous Mt. Gox hack, the latter's private key holder remaining unidentified.

CryptoQuant has labeled this surge in selling "old" Bitcoins as the largest release of long-term supply in the cryptocurrency's history.