Common Sense Media has rated ChatGPT for Teens as an 'unacceptable risk' due to safety concerns, calling for improvements in its safety measures.
Common Sense Media has identified the ChatGPT for Teens feature as presenting an "unacceptable risk" due to deficiencies in parental controls, crisis management, and plagiarism safeguards.
Aaaand another AI chatbot failure. OpenAI promised to make ChatGPT a safer experience for teens, but it didn’t make the grade. Our Youth AI Safety Institute rated ChatGPT for Teens an Unacceptable Risk for kids. Check out our thread to learn why:
— Common Sense Media (@CommonSense) October 7, 2026
This nonprofit organization conducted a thorough evaluation of ChatGPT for Teens, uncovering notable inadequacies in its safety protocols. Experts are urging OpenAI to limit access to users under 18 until these concerns are addressed.
The Youth AI Safety Institute analyzed over 4,000 queries from teenage users, aged 13 to 17, both before and after the feature's launch on August 18, 2026, with insights from child mental health professionals.
Risks for Parents to Consider
During testing, new accounts enabled teenagers to engage with ChatGPT about sensitive topics such as suicidal ideation and self-harm for an hour without alerting parents. For accounts with prior conversations on these matters, alerts were triggered more frequently.
In crisis response scenarios, ChatGPT failed to recommend professional help or hotlines in over a quarter of relevant tests. The evaluation revealed that the chatbot's performance fell below the 95% safety threshold in three out of five assessed risk categories.
Concerns Over Plagiarism Protections
The study also scrutinized the "Study Mode" feature, where the chatbot could provide complete solutions via a "Show me the answer" button. Additionally, parental time limits could be circumvented by omitting the @study prefix from requests.
Experts raised questions about the effectiveness of age detection, noting that the chatbot sometimes failed to switch to the teen mode even when users explicitly stated their age as 13.
Chatbot's Emotional Mimicry Raises Concerns
Even in teen mode, ChatGPT continued to express its own emotions and preferences, which Common Sense Media warns could foster emotional dependency on AI. The organization emphasizes the necessity of curbing the chatbot's behavior that suggests it possesses feelings or personal interest in users.
OpenAI's Response to the Criticism
OpenAI has contested the findings, suggesting that the evaluation may have occurred before the full activation of parental controls and highlighting its ongoing efforts to enhance protections for minors.
Common Sense Media has called for an independent review of OpenAI’s safety measures, recommending improvements in five key areas: age verification, parental alerts, crisis responses, plagiarism safeguards, and limitations on the chatbot's anthropomorphic behavior.
In a related development, Florida's state government filed a lawsuit against OpenAI and its CEO Sam Altman in June, alleging aggressive marketing of ChatGPT to teenagers.